Taanis

Taanis 25a: The mysterious chicken

Taanis 25a: A man once passed by Rabbi Chanina ben Dosa’s house and left some chickens. His wife found them, and he said to her, “Do not eat their eggs.”

תענית כה ע”א: מעשה ועבר אדם אחד על פתח ביתו והניח שם תרנגולין, ומצאתן אשתו של רבי חנינא בן דוסא, ואמר לה: אל תאכלי מביציהן.

Rabbi Moshe Soloveitchik related that when he was a young boy, it once happened that a chicken started marching into his family’s yard every day, laying an egg and then leaving. His father, Reb Chaim, decided to find out where the chicken was coming from, so that he could return the eggs to their rightful owner. Reb Chaim followed the chicken and suddenly it vanished into thin air! “Maybe there is someone who owed me money and died before he could pay me back. This chicken could be his gilgul,” Reb Chaim suggested. He went and checked his notebook, and indeed there was such a person who had died recently.

The next day, when the chicken came, Reb Chaim came up to it and said, “If you are so-and-so who owed me money, then I forgive you!” And the chicken never came back again.

Source: Chashukei Chemed on Beitzah, p. 8

[In Bava Metzia 28b we learn that one who finds a lost animal, and is holding it while waiting for its owner to claim it, should use the animal’s products (e.g. the work value of a horse) to pay for its food supply. Thus Rabbi Chanina ben Dosa was allowed to use the eggs of the chickens he found, because he was feeding them; he was being strict beyond the letter of the law. In Reb Chaim’s case, if the chicken had not been a gilgul, he would have had to return the eggs, since he was not feeding it.]

Taanis

Taanis 19a: Earthquakes in Yerushalayim

Taanis 19a. And so too a city where there is disease or falling pieces of buildings, that city fasts and blows the shofar, and all the surrounding cities fast, but do not blow the shofar.

Shulchan Aruch Orach Chaim 576:4: We fast because of falling pieces of buildings: if there were many incidents in the city of walls in good condition, not on the riverbank, falling, then it is a calamity and we fast and blow shofar because of it. Similarly, if there was an earthquake or a strong wind that knocked down buildings and killed people, we fast and blow shofar [so that it should not happen again].

תענית יט ע”א. וכן עיר שיש בה דבר או מפולת, אותה העיר מתענה ומתרעת וכל סביבותיה מתענות ולא מתריעות.

שו”ע או”ח תקע”ו ס”ד. וכן מתענין על המפולת שבעיר כיצד הרי שרבתה בעיר מפולת כותלים בריאים שאינן עומדין בצד הנהר ה״ז צרה ומתענין ומתריעין עליה וכן על הרעש ועל הרוחות שהם מפילים הבנין והורגים מתענים ומתריעין עליהם:

The Kaf Hachaim (Orach Chaim 576:26) quotes the Pri Haaretz who says that in Yerushalayim, if there was falling debris or an earthquake, we don’t fast so that it shouldn’t continue, because there is a tradition that falling debris never hurt anyone in Yerushalayim.

He then cites an example: in 5687 (1927) on the 11th of Tammuz, an earthquake struck Yerushalayim and its environs. Many walls fell down; other walls cracked. Miraculously, no one in Yerushalayim was killed; only in the surrounding villages were people killed. All observers marvelled at Hashem’s protection of the Jewish people, and even those who normally did not admit to anything supernatural believed in Hashem and testified that the hand of Hashem had done this.

Similarly, the Pe’as Hashulchan writes in a letter (printed at the beginning of his sefer) that in the famous earthquake of 1837, while hundreds died in Tiberias and Shechem, Yerushalayim had damage to some houses but “thank G-d, not a single person was harmed.”

[We could ask a question here: the Gemara in Berachos 3a states, “It is forbidden to enter a ruined building for three reasons: so as not to arouse suspicion that he is going there to commit a sin, due to falling debris and due to the demons.” The Gemara then explains why we need all these reasons: for each reason, there exists a case where only that reason applies. For example, if the ruins are new and located within a city, then they are unlikely to fall and there are no demons; the only reason would be suspicion. Now, if in Yerushalayim no one is ever harmed by falling debris, then why didn’t the Gemara give the case of a ruin in Yerushalayim?

One might have replied that this special Divine protection was not in effect yet in the Gemara’s time. However, Avos Derabbi Nosson 35:1 lists as one of the ten miracles in Yerushalayim that “falling debris never harmed anyone.” The commentary Kisei Rachamim explains that this means an earthquake.

Another question is that the Gemara says that if the tragedy happened in one city, the surrounding cities also fast. If so, why does the Kaf Hachaim say that Yerushalayim doesn’t fast? They should at least fast because of the surrounding cities that were harmed, as they were in 1927.

It must be that the Kaf Hachaim understood that the reason for fasting over a tragedy in another city is not to pray for the other city – they must pray for themselves – but rather to pray that the tragedy shouldn’t spread to this city.]